This is an archive of a past election.
See http://www.smartvoter.org/ca/state/ for current information.
San Mateo, Santa Clara County, CA June 5, 2012 Election
Smart Voter

Education Reform: Getting District and Charter Schools to Work Together

By Christopher Kent Chiang

Candidate for State Senator; District 13

This information is provided by the candidate
Chris Chiang proposes allowing whole school districts, if they voluntarily choose, to convert their entire district into a charter district, with the full authority to retain and pursue parcel taxes and school bonds. Districts would receive funding in the form of a general purpose grants, so they, rather than Sacramento, would be able to decide how to use their funds best. These proposed charter districts would continue under their existing locally negotiated teacher agreements.
Currently 912 schools operate as charter schools outside the 2,491 pages of the state education code (compare that to the 91 pages that charter schools must follow). There is a learned helplessness when the state controls all key decisions in a school. Increasingly, more traditional school districts like Cambrian are converting their own schools into charter schools in order to get a mega waiver from the majority of those well-intended but stifling state education rules.

Chris Chiang proposes allowing whole school districts, if they voluntarily choose, to convert their entire district into a charter district, with the full authority to retain and pursue parcel taxes and school bonds. Districts would receive funding in the form of a general purpose grants, so they, rather than Sacramento, would be able to decide how to use their funds best. These proposed charter districts would continue under their existing locally negotiated teacher agreements.

The goal isn't to have charters compete with district schools or for district schools to escape from locally bargained agreements with their teachers, but to give district schools the same means to innovate as they had pre-Prop 13. You have no choice but to take initiative when you are making all your own decisions. We can't turn back funding overnight, but we can give back to our schools and principals the freedom to redesign their schools for the 21st century.

As with all charters, these proposed charter districts must academically perform and complete financial audits to keep their freedom. They must abide by all laws that protect students with disabilities. If the charter district fails to perform, it will be reverted back to a traditional district. This bold reform will direct dollars away from bureaucracy and into the classroom.

The focus of the state must be to improve district schools. Six million students attend district schools compared to the less than half a million attend charter schools. Logistically charters are not able to replace the majority of district schools. Rather, we need to focus on creating an environment where charter school innovations can transfer over to district schools.

The legislature has been too passive in guiding charter schools towards collaboration with district schools. Prop 39 gave the legislature the power to define how school property needs to be shared between district and charter schools. The state's lack of leadership has allowed Prop 39 to become a growing source of contention between charters and districts.

Accepting that charters should be a testing ground for new ideas rather than replacements for district schools means we should expect a high rate of failure. If we want innovation from charter schools, we must also expect many will fail. Those that do should be shut down quickly, but risk is necessary for new ideas. Those that succeed, their practices should be quickly shared with district schools. Seeing charters as a tool for district reform brings needed clarity to state policy.

Candidate Page || Feedback to Candidate || This Contest
June 2012 Home (Ballot Lookup) || About Smart Voter


ca/state Created from information supplied by the candidate: April 15, 2012 12:53
Smart Voter <http://www.smartvoter.org/>
Copyright © League of Women Voters of California Education Fund.
The League of Women Voters neither supports nor opposes candidates for public office or political parties.