This is an archive of a past election.
See http://www.smartvoter.org/ca/state/ for current information.
Repeals Recent Legislation That Would Allow Businesses to Lower Their Tax Liability
State of California
Initiative Statute - Majority Approval Required
Fail: 3,939,118 / 41.9% Yes votes ...... 5,461,674 / 58.1% No votes
Index of all Propositions
|Results as of Nov 30 4:33pm, 100.0% of Precincts Reporting (24845/24845)
|Information shown below: Summary | Fiscal Impact | Yes/No Meaning | Impartial Analysis | Arguments |
Should recent tax law changes that allow some businesses to pay lower state income tax be repealed?
This proposition would change three provisions of California's laws for taxing businesses. As indicated below, these provisions have been changed recently as part of state budget agreements between the Legislature and the Governor. Under current law, all of these recent changes will be in effect by the 2011 tax year.
Businesses' Use of Financial Losses. Under federal and state tax laws, in a year when a business has more deductible expenses than income, the business has a net operating loss (NOL). A business with an NOL in one year generally can use it to reduce its taxes when it makes a profit in some later years. This is known as a "carryforward" of losses. Federal tax law also allows businesses to "carry back" losses. In other words, federal law allows a business to use an NOL from one year to reduce its taxes in an earlier year. These mechanisms--both carryforwards and carrybacks--have been put in place to recognize that business income and/or expenses can vary significantly from year to year.
A law approved by the Legislature and the Governor in 2008 allows carrybacks for state business taxes for the first time, starting in 2011. Specifically, this new law will allow a business to use an NOL from 2011 or later to reduce its state taxes for the two years before the NOL was generated. For example, a business that had profits and paid taxes in 2009 but has a loss in 2011 may deduct its 2011 NOL against its 2009 taxable income. The business would file an amended tax return for 2009 and receive a tax refund. In addition, the 2008 law extends the carryforward time allowed from 10 years to 20 years.
Determination of Income of Multistate Businesses' Taxed by California. Businesses often operate in many states. To determine how much of the income of a multistate business is taxed by the state, California law now uses a formula that involves three factors:
Ability of Businesses to Share Tax Credits. California tax law allows tax credits that can reduce a business' taxes. If, for example, a business is able to use tax credits worth $1 million, this reduces the business' state taxes by $1 million. These tax credits are given to businesses doing certain things that the state wants to encourage. For example, a business that spends money in California to develop a new technology product may earn a "research and development" tax credit. If a business has credits which exceed the amount of taxes it owes in a given year, it will have unused credits. (Typically, these unused credits can be carried forward to be used in future years.)
Many business organizations consist of a group of business entities. This is called a "unitary group" if it meets certain conditions, such as operating jointly or operating under the same management. For example, one business in a group may develop a product, and another business in the group may sell that product. Tax credits are given to individual business entities--not unitary groups.
A law approved by the Legislature and the Governor in 2008 allows a business with available tax credits to transfer unused tax credits to another business in the same group. Shared credits can be used to reduce taxes in 2010 and later years. There are certain limitations to this credit sharing in the law. Some of these credits have been transferred already.
This proposition repeals the business tax law changes passed in 2008 and 2009 described above. As such, this measure would return tax policies in these areas to the way they were prior to the recent law changes. The effects of this proposition are summarized in Figure 1.
Restricts Ability of a Business to Use Operating Losses to Lower Taxes. This proposition prevents a business from using an NOL carryback to reduce its taxes for previous years. Businesses could still use NOLs to reduce their taxes in future years--though they would have 10 years to use each NOL, rather than 20 years.
See Figure 1 (click here and scroll down to view) Effects of Proposition 24 on California Business Tax Law
Ends Ability of a Multistate Business to Choose How Its California Income Is Determined. This proposition eliminates the option that multistate businesses will have to choose between two formulas to determine the portion of their income subject to California state taxes. Instead, businesses' taxable income in California would continue to be determined based on the formula currently in use which considers businesses' sales, property, and payroll. (The tax law used for businesses that only do business in California would be unchanged by this part of the proposition.)
Ends Ability of a Business to Share Tax Credits Within a Unitary Group. This proposition prevents business entities within a unitary group from sharing tax credits in the future. (While it is not certain, it appears that businesses would be able to use tax credits that already have been transferred to them.)
What is Prop 24?
Secretary of State
League of Women Voters of California Education Fund
Secretary of State