This is an archive of a past election.
See for current information.
State of Pennsylvania May 19, 2009 Election
Smart Voter

Statement from Judge Panella

By Jack A. Panella

Candidate for Justice; Pennsylvania Supreme Court; Democratic Party

This information is provided by the candidate
Running for statewide office is a challenging endeavor, and I didn't come to the decision to run lightly. I am motivated by a firm commitment to public service, and the belief that the citizens of Pennsylvania deserve a judicial system that strikes the right balance of independence and public accountability.

During my nearly 18 years on the bench, I have had the opportunity to preside over a wide variety of civil and criminal legal proceedings, from sensational and widely publicized murder trials to highly complex mass tort cases. I have extensive experience and knowledge of judicial ethics and discipline. I am the Chair of the Judicial Auditing Agency; and I am the only judge in the history of Pennsylvania to have served as both the Chair of the Judicial Conduct Board and President Judge of the Court of Judicial Discipline.

I have been active in efforts to increase awareness and to make the courts more responsive and accessible to the public. In 2004, I was appointed to the Commission for Justice Initiatives, where I am the Chair of the Public Education and Community Outreach subcommittee. As part of my responsibilities, I conceived and wrote a popular short film on the history and operation of the Pennsylvania Judiciary. The video has been used as an educational tool in classrooms around the state and can be viewed on the websites of the Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts and the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania.

Also, I chaired the committee to redesign the Supreme Court website, in order to make the website more user friendly and provide assistance to self represented litigants. There is a great need in Pennsylvania, especially in the family law divisions of the trial courts, to provide helpful information to the public about the operation and administration of the court system.

I have worked to foster cooperation between Pennsylvania's legislative and judicial branches. As a member of the Pennsylvania Conference of State Trial Judges, I was the Chair of the Commonwealth Partners Program, which involves statewide meetings attended by judges and legislators to discuss and resolve issues of mutual concern. In recognition of the success of this program, I received the President's Award from the Conference of State Trial Judges in 2002.

One of the recent accomplishments that I am most proud of is the publication of the Sexual Violence Benchbook. I am one of the principal authors of the book, which provides judges with a comprehensive understanding of Pennsylvania's current sexual offense laws. The book has received widespread acclaim from the legal community and has been hailed in the press as a valuable resource for judges overseeing cases dealing with sexual crimes, violence and abuse.

I am proud of my work as a judge over the last 18 years and I believe I am the candidate with the experience and priorities to not only ensure fair treatment in our courts, but to help restore much needed public confidence in them.

I am honored to have received a rating of "highly recommended" by the Pennsylvania Bar Association. In their announcement, they cited my "sound judicial temperament and exceptional administrative ability" and stated that I "possesses a rare combination of intellect, energy and skills" that qualify me for the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. I also received a Bar Association Rating of "highly recommended" for my 2003 campaign for Superior Court.

Judges must remain impartial and unbiased. I constantly work to maintain my judicial independence by making promises to no one and by faithfully performing my job to uphold the Constitution of Pennsylvania.

With campaigns for judicial offices attracting more attention and larger campaign contributions, the potential for, and perceptions of, conflicts of interest have grown tremendously. Additionally, I recognize that the misdeeds of some of my less scrupulous colleagues have severely damaged the public's faith in our legal system.

First we must increase judicial oversight. As part of its administrative responsibilities, the Supreme Court should increase the number of investigators for the Judicial Conduct Board, and implement programs to check statistics on magisterial courts and trial courts on a number of specific items which generate income for vendors who do business within the court system, such as fines/costs collection, placements in juvenile courts, and professional fees in family court and juvenile court. In my role as a member of both the Judicial Conduct Board and the Court of Judicial Discipline, I was exposed to allegations of abuses by judges in the granting and awarding of these types of contracts.

Secondly, Judges must vigilantly defend our judicial independence, and in cases where there is a clear conflict of interest, we must recuse ourselves. By taking a firm stand and holding ourselves up to the highest ethical standards, judges can help remove the incentive for those who would try to purchase influence over Pennsylvania's legal system.

Candidate Page || This Contest
May 2009 Home (Ballot Lookup) || About Smart Voter

pa/state Created from information supplied by the candidate: May 14, 2009 11:59
Smart Voter <>
Copyright © League of Women Voters of California Education Fund.
The League of Women Voters neither supports nor opposes candidates for public office or political parties.