This is an archive of a past election.
See http://www.smartvoter.org/ca/la/ for current information.
LWV League of Women Voters of California Education Fund
Smart Voter
Los Angeles County, CA November 7, 2006 Election
Measure J
Technical changes for Proposition F Regional Fire Stations
City of Los Angeles

Charter Amendment & Ordinance - 2/3 Majority Approval Required

Pass: 477,933 / 76.84% Yes votes ...... 144,074 / 23.16% No votes

See Also: Index of all Measures

Information shown below: Summary | Fiscal Impact | Impartial Analysis | Arguments | Tax Rate Statement |

To lower costs and provide design flexibility for new regional fire stations, shall Proposition F (voter approved November 7, 2000) be changed to allow regional fire stations to be built on one or more sites totaling less than 2 acres, instead of requiring a single 2 +acre site, if the Fire Department decides that the station can be built to fully meet operational needs?

Summary:
Title

Technical changes for Proposition F Regional Fire Stations
City of Los Angeles Proposition J.

The Issue:

To lower costs and provide design flexibility for new regional fire stations, shall Proposition F (voter approved November 7, 2000) be changed to allow regional fire stations to be built on one or more site totaling less than 2 acres, instead of requiring a single 2-acre site, if the Fire Department decides that the station can be built to fully met operational needs?

The Situation

Proposition F provided funds for new standard and regional fire stations. A regional station has both a standard fire station and a training facility, traditionally located on a single 2-acre site. The Proposal

This measure allows the Fire Department and City Engineer to build the training facility of a regional station on a separate site if necessary. The total site could be less than 2 acres if the Fire Department confirms that the needs of the Fire Department and public safety are fully met.

A Yes Vote Means:

You want to allow the Fire Department the flexibility to build regional fire stations on more than one site of less than two acres.

A No Vote Means:

You do not want to allow the Fire Department the flexibility to build regional fire stations on more than one site of less than two acres.

Fiscal Impact from City Administative Officer William T. Fukioka:
This technical adjustment to the Proposition F Bond Program will result in no change to the City's debt service obligations nor impact the General Fund beyond the cost of placing the measure on the ballot.

Impartial Analysis from Chief Legislative Analyst Gerry F. Miller
This measure would clarify the provisions of Proposition F, approved by the voters on November 7, 2000, to allow a new regional fire station funded by Proposition F to be designed and built on one or more properties totalling less than two acres.

Proposition F detailed 20 fire and emergency facilities to be built using bond funds, including the construction of new regional fire stations. The purpose of the new regional fire stations is to provide training and other facilities at or near standard fire stations so that, when in training, firefighters remain in the areas that they serve and are available to respond to emergency calls. The Proposition F ballot information described a regional fire station as, among other things, sitting on two acres. As a result, the City Attorney has advised that pursuant to Proposition F, regional fire stations must be designed and built on a single site of at least two acres.

For new regional fire stations specified in Proposition F that are located in densely developed areas, it is difficult to identify a single two acre site that can be acquired at a reasonable cost and without serious disruption to the surrounding community. The Fire Department and the City Engineer have determined that the components of a regional fire station can be built on two or more sites within close proximity, or the facility can be designed to fit on a single site of less than two acres. This will provide the City with flexibility in siting the regional fire stations to reduce costs and lessen the impact on the surrounding community. The City Attorney has determined that, in order to proceed with either option, voter approval of this technical change to clarify the language in Proposition F will be required.

Approval of this measure will give the City the option to build regional fire stations on two or more sites totalling less than two acres, or on a single site of less than two acres, when the Fire Department determines that the facility can be designed to meet its operational needs.

No additional bond or taxing authorization is provided by this measure.

This measure would become effective with a two-thirds vote.

  Official Information

L.A. City Election Division

Los Angeles Fire Department
This election is archived. Any links to sources outside of Smart Voter may no longer be active. No further links will be added to this page.
Links to sources outside of Smart Voter are provided for information only and do not imply endorsement.

Arguments For Measure J
The approval of this clarification will allow the construction of new Regional Fire/Paramedic stations at more than one location. The cost savings is immediate to the public simply because the purchase of smaller land parcels is cheaper than a more expensive, larger two-acre commercial site. The intent

of Proposition F, as it relates to Regional Fire/Paramedic Stations, will be achieved in a more efficient manner.

With the approval of the technical change to Proposition F, the Citizens of Los Angeles will speed up the construction timelines, reduce costs and allow for more flexibility in fire station placement. Fire Department resources will remain available in their local communities for mandatory and required training.

The Fire Stations will be more accessible to the local community; existing neighborhoods will remain intact and the impact of construction of new fire stations on the surrounding communities would be minimized. The Fire Department would continue to fully meet operational needs to protect the public health and safety. The change would allow the construction of a more flexible fire station floor plan, which will improve service to those communities.

We urge you to support this technical change to ensure that all areas of the City have the fire services they need at the lowest possible cost.

TOM LABONGE
Councilmember,
4th District

WILLIAM R. BAMATTRE
Fire Chief, City of LA

JOHN P. MILLER
President, Chief Officer’s Assoc.

ERIC GARCETTI
Councilmember,
13th District

PAT McOSKER
President, UFLAC

(No arguments against Measure J were submitted)

Tax Rate Statement from City Administative Officer William T. Fukioka
The City Administrative Officer reports that there is no change to the City’s debt service obligations, thereby continuing the existing tax rate, as a result of the technical adjustment to the Proposition F Bond Program.


Los Angeles Home Page || Statewide Links || About Smart Voter || Feedback
Created: January 4, 2007 09:34 PST
Smart Voter <http://www.smartvoter.org/>
Copyright © League of Women Voters of California Education Fund   http://www.lwvc.org
The League of Women Voters neither supports nor opposes candidates for public office or political parties.